Tort Reform: Is it Constitutional?

The previous post regarding "tort reform" presented data from an empirical study which showed that the majority of elected judges in Texas, both Republican and Democrat, believe that tort reform is unnecessary. In this post, guest author and Houston Trial Attorney Steve Waldman weighs in on how the current tort reform bills could affect the Constitution and the Bill of Rights.

Constitution Demolition - Also Known as TortReform3   
By: Steve Waldman

When did the Bill of Rights lose all its amendments other than the Second and the Tenth?  All I hear the defenders of the Constitution actually defend are the right to bear arms and states' rights.  What happened to the right of trial by jury?  When did it get cast on the refuse pile?  Are the freedoms of speech and religion next?

Can you imagine the Two Commandments?  I am just as much against graven images and coveting as the next guy, but aren't the Ten Commandments a packaged deal?  Is the Bill of Rights any different?

What is being proposed in Austin right now is a total elimination of jury trials, particularly in cases where companies cause the most harm.   

Lawmakers are proposing a "Voluntary Compensation Plan," which allows companies to set up "Plans" 90 days after causing death or injury to two or more people.  BP can blow up half of Texas City and be immune from liability beyond whatever "Plan" it chose to adopt.  The statute has no requirements for what the plan covers and punishes you if you attempt to go outside the plan.  And, to make sure you are unable to find an attorney to help you, attorney's fees are capped at 5% of what you recover from a Plan.  Have you ever fought with a "Plan" over benefits?     

Also being proposed is a British-style "loser pays" law that will make a plaintiff who loses a lawsuit and his or her attorney liable to pay the winner's attorney's fees, litigation costs, travel expenses and expert witness fees.  This only applies to plaintiffs.  Defendants are never required to pay the plaintiff's costs.  If this passes, anyone who is injured due to the negligence of someone else will risk financial ruin if he or she files suit.

So what can you do?  You can get involved.  Write your state legislator and state senator and tell them you care about your constitutional rights, including the right to have your day in court.  Stand up for the Constitution!  

You can also get involved through Texas Watch, "a non-partisan citizen advocacy organization dedicated to ensuring that corporations and insurance companies are accountable to their customers."  Alex Winslow, the director of Texas Watch, is a corporate watchdog.  If you are upset that your rights have been taken from you, contact Texas Watch and check out their Take Action and Share Your Story links. 

If you have a story to tell, Texas Watch wants to hear it.  You can also email Texas Watch by clicking on this link.

Reprinted with permission.

   

Legislative Update: Kari's Law

In 2006 former pastor Matt Baker murdered his wife Kari in their Hewitt, McLennan County, Texas home and staged the scene to look like a suicide.  

The responding police officers and emergency personnel followed standard protocol when they arrived at the Baker house which dictated that, in McLennan County, a justice of the peace conduct an “inquest into the death of a person who dies if the person commits suicide or the circumstances of the death indicate that the death may have been caused by suicide.”  Texas Code of Crim. Pro. §49.04.  


Texas law at that time stated that an “inquest meant an investigation into the cause and circumstances of the death…, and a determination, made with or without a formal court hearing, as to whether the death was caused by an unlawful act.”  Texas Code of Crim. Pro §49.01.  Moreover, a justice of the peace could conduct the “inquest…at any other place determined to be reasonable by the justice.”  


In the Baker case, this meant that the presiding justice of the peace was able to investigate Kari Baker’s death and determine the cause via a late night phone call from the responding police officers without getting out of bed.  Finally, a justice of the peace had the sole discretion of whether to order an autopsy.  Texas Code of Crim. Pro §49.10. 
   
An autopsy was later performed in the Baker case, but only after a formal inquest hearing was granted and after Kari had been interred.  The results from the autopsy provided crucial evidence that helped prove that Kari had not committed suicide but had in fact been murdered by Matt Baker.  


If a full or partial autopsy would have been a mandatory requirement for apparent suicides, like it is in other states such as Oklahoma or Georgia, crucial evidence against Mr. Baker would have been better preserved.

                   

In the current legislative session Texas House Representative Charles "Doc" Anderson of McLennan County has introduced House Bill 3546, referred to as Kari's Law by its supporters, which would substantially change this very important area of Texas law such that autopsies become mandatory anytime a death is apparently caused by suicide.


With all of the other duties of a justice of the peace –performing marriages, issuing warrants, setting bail, conducting criminal and civil trials- it seems that determining death is one duty that should be void of discretion and ultimately up to a medical professional.   Accordingly, this Bill and its author are worthy of support.   

Legislative Update

Yesterday marked the halfway point of the 82nd legislature in Texas.  Now with only 69 days left there are a series of bills that are moving through the legislative process that will have a direct impact on the civil justice and criminal justice system in Texas.

If you are interested in the process of how a House or Senate Bill becomes a law in Texas, you can see a diagram of the legislative process here or you can read about it more here.

If you are interested in searching for specific bills, or searching for a bill by the text of the bill you can do so here.

Additional entries about specific bills will follow soon.